What Is the Point of Strategy? From Reactive to Proactive Thinking

• Written By Jeff Humble

strategy proactive reactive moves

Some people spend their whole career reacting to someone else’s moves.

When you’re fighting the daily fires, it’s hard to find time for anything but reacting, but if you don’t get proactive, you might end up somebody else’s pawn.

This article is about who reacts to the future and who gets to shape it.

Learning reactive vs. proactive thinking is a great way to learn the power of strategy. Strategists take a proactive approach and try to force the competition to react. It’s a three-dimensional chess game in which the strategist can come to dominate entire markets.

Being reactive means forfeiting control

I remember bracing myself every Monday morning for the worst. We never knew what the new agenda would be, but we knew that it would throw our work into chaos. Sometimes, all it took was for the founder to read a single article to change the company agenda. When a competitor released a new feature, the reaction was even worse. Everything had to stop until we figured out how to deal with the competition.

Sure, we were reacting to the changing market, but it was hard to focus on delivering value in that environment.

When reacting is your job, you do not control what comes next. It can feel like you’re running on a treadmill that is going too fast, and somebody else keeps changing the speed.

[GIF by thechemicalbrothers]

For businesses, the ones changing the speed on that treadmill are the competitors that are proactively shifting the market in their favor because they understand strategy. Since you’re only reacting to the pressure of other companies, you’re doomed to let other companies shape the future.

Working at a reactive organization is exhausting. The non-strategic leaders demand that we “beat the competitors” by getting to feature parity with them, and worse yet, we have to “do it better.” This is a losing game because the competitor beat us to the feature in the first place because they’re better at that type of thing. You work extra hard to keep up with everyone, ultimately becoming bad at what your competitors are already good at.

With all the reacting, you don’t have time to get ahead of the curve. What can you do in such a situation?

Being reactive is the opposite of strategy

This approach of reactingto your environment instead of actively shaping it is the opposite of strategy. It involves letting competitors, trends, or even customers distract you from being strategic.

[GIF by @dualvoidanima]

Being reactive (and un-strategic) looks like:

  • The shotgun approach: Trying everything to see what works wastes time and resources.
  • Borrowing tactics: This involves borrowing a tactic from a strategy in one context that makes no sense in the current context.
  • Following best practicesCan make short-term gains, but it’s hard to win since your competitors follow the same best practices.
  • Chasing trends: This might work in the short term, but it can distract from forging your unique and defendable path.
  • Over-delivering customer requests: While it might feel good to grant every customer request, your customers only know what’s best for them. You have to figure out if it’s good for the business.
  • **Over-delivering sales requests:**Similar to above, salespeople are highly incentivized to promise customers the world, but this isn’t always good for the company in the long term.
  • Outworking or outspending the competition: This might help you stay ahead of the competition for a bit, say with venture funding or a motivated team, but without proactively forging your strategic direction, it won’t last.

There’s nothing wrong with these reactive approaches on their own. You can follow trends or best practices and still make a significant impact. I’m just saying that being proactive and following a strategy would be way better.

[GIF by dualvoidanima]

Being proactive (and strategic) looks like:

  • Focusing on the essence: Doing fewer things better can save time and resources.
  • Making bold choices: Decide beforehand which direction you will take.
  • Doing the opposite: Break the norms. When the competitors zig, you should zag.
  • Building to be different: Only take action when it aligns with the strategy’s direction.
  • Doing more with less: Rather than fight a losing game against competitors, do your own thing and carve out a defendable niche.

Steve Jobs is a good example of a strategic CEO who was very proactive. He was so proactive that it sometimes felt like he was a decade ahead of the competition. He took a single technology, touchscreen interfaces, and built product lines like the iPod, iPhone, and iPad out of it. Today, the market struggles to compete with the seamless blend of software and hardware that Apple pioneered. The strategic niche that Apple created with personal computer devices has held for decades.

You don’t have to be the CEO to be proactive and strategic. Sheryl Sandberg was the Chief Operating Officer at Facebook in 2008, when Facebook was growing at an insane rate but didn’t have a plan to get to profitability. Sheryl pioneered data-driven targeted ads in the news feed, a radical departure from banner ads. This monetization strategy enabled Facebook to dominate the ad business, a proactive move that still earns Facebook millions.

You don’t even have to create an artifact like a presentation deck to be strategic. Katherine Johnson was a NASA mathematician during the Apollo missions. At the time, many women did complex calculations by hand but were not included in critical decision-making processes. Katherine realized that this could have dire consequences during emergencies. She inserted herself into critical conversations and pioneered computer-aided calculations so that her strategic approaches could prevent disasters.

The most successful people don’t wait for events to unfold. They engineer outcomes to their advantage, and strategy provides the tools to do that.

What is the purpose of strategy?

What does strategy actually do for us? More than a plan, it’s developing a theory for thinking and working on the future that helps us move from reactive to proactive thinking.

[GIF by dualvoidanima]

Max McKeown gives us a nice overview of what strategy does for us:

"Strategy is about shaping the future…Brilliant strategy is the best route to desirable ends with available means."

Michael Porter is one of the most famous strategists. I like how he describes its purpose:

“Strategy is about setting yourself apart from the competition. It's not a matter of being better at what you do - it's a matter of being different at what you do.”

Being proactive will improve your future, but strategy will help you shape it. Strategy almost always has a higher return on investment than other activities at work.

Here’s how strategy work is different:

  • It’s about focusing on fewer options: Instead of considering every opportunity from scratch for every project, a clear strategy automatically rejects misaligned options.

  • It’s just as much about what you won’t do as what you will do: Constraints create focus, and saying no to the wrong things enables the right things to thrive.

  • It turns weaknesses into strengths: When resources are limited, a great strategy finds ways to win with what you already have.

    It helps you deliver like nobody else can. Strategy is about finding your unique edge and embracing it.

  • It compounds over time: Just like good investments, good strategic decisions build on each other to create a long-term advantage, especially if you evolve your strategy with time.

Even a bad strategy can provide some of those benefits; at its worst, it will still make you think about the future, so it’s always a good idea.

How being reactive is disguised as strategy

Many companies go through the motions of making a strategy and end up with something reactive disguised as a strategy.

You’re missing the point when your strategy is built on reactive thinking. Strategies about “being the leader” and “becoming #1” are often reactive, thinking about competitors in disguise as a strategy.

Here’s a common scenario of reactive strategy:

  1. See the competition release a new feature.
  2. Create a quarterly goal to get the team to copy the feature.
  3. Push the team hard to get it done in a quarter.
  4. Never take the time to measure the impact of the feature.
  5. Find a new competitor feature to copy next quarter and repeat.
  6. After a few quarters, invent some grand, unreachable vision that rationalizes the quarterly goals to make it seem like the current trajectory is part of some plan.
  7. Call this Frankenstein of goals, vision, and reactivity a Strategy.

We become short-sighted when we chase disparate goals like carrots on a string. After several quarters of chasing random goals, you might wake up and not know what your company stands for anymore.

To avoid shortsightedness, you’ll have to find the time to get ahead of it. You’ll have to figure out how to be proactive, and strategy is a whole methodology for doing that at the company level.

Examples of companies leveraging strategy

At an individual level, strategy allows product leaders and teams to work smarter, not just harder. But what does this look like in practice?

Here are some real-world examples of strategic companies that have used strategy to proactively set the future of competition in their markets.

  • Airbnb’s shift from renting air mattresses to an experiences platform: Airbnb could have stopped at merely competing with hotels, but they decided to strengthen their competitive advantage with their strategy to redefine the entire industry around experiences. This allowed Airbnb to define this new travel category rather than fight price wars with hotels.
  • Nike’s move toward direct-to-consumer shopping: For a long time, Nike relied on third-party retailers like FootLocker, and its efforts were focused on beating competitors within those stores. In the early 2010s, Nike changed its strategy by selling its clothing on its website, apps, and flagship stores, allowing it to take control of its customer relationship.
  • Basecamp’s focus on a calm company culture: In a world of productivity tools obsessed with growth at all costs, Basecamp’s strategy was to optimize for long-term sustainability over hypergrowth, ensuring profitability and resilience. You can peek at this contrarian philosophy in public-facing docs like the 37signals Guide to Making Decisions.
  • Shopify empowers small businesses: Shopify didn’t just build another e-commerce platform like the market dominator Amazon. Instead, it provided small businesses with enterprise-level tools, betting on the rise of independent online stores rather than the big behemoth Amazon.

These examples show that strategy isn’t about working harder or chasing the latest trends. It’s about making calculated choices, committing to what will set you apart, and building an approach that creates leverage over time.

The benefits of having a strategy

I’m not going to lie to you. Shifting to proactive takes a lot of work. But know that a clear strategy gives you many benefits:

  • Say no with confidence. Not every opportunity aligns with your goals, and strategy provides a filter for decision-making.
  • Create work that compounds. Instead of spinning in circles, the strategy builds long-term momentum.
  • Find leverage. The most effective teams don’t outwork everyone; they work smarter. Finding a lever can help you do more with fewer resources.
  • Avoid getting lost in complexity. A good strategy cuts through the noise and ensures every decision builds on a long-term vision.
  • Turn constraints into competitive advantages. A strategy allows you to use limited resources more effectively than companies with more money or human power.
  • Position yourself to win. Instead of responding to trends, set them. Make your own game rather than playing someone else’s.

While these benefits won’t last forever, they will last much longer than the quarterly cycles of reactive thinking.

Real-life examples of people who have benefited from leveraging strategy

[GIF by dualvoidanima]

I teach a course on designing strategy twice a year, and every year I see dozens of examples of people integrating strategy into their practice. None of these people are CEOs. While some are managers, the majority are just regular individual contributors.

The Ambitious Designer: becoming head of the department

An ambitious newcomer joins a product team and quickly realizes that everyone is bogged down by repetitive tasks, and no one owns the long-term direction. They take it upon themselves to fill the gap—analyzing design patterns, presenting compelling insights, and helping leadership realize the power of a team strategy. This proactive work helps them quickly become the head of the team, gaining influence far beyond their initial role.

The Product Manager: from firefighter to visionary

This person was a weary product manager who found themselves constantly reacting to stakeholder demands. Instead of staying in a reactive loop, they start gathering insights from customers, prioritizing what will have the most long-term impact, and shaping the roadmap accordingly. They proactively developed a product strategy with a cohesive theory rather than a reactive list of features to build. Over time, they shift from being an executor to someone who sets direction, ultimately driving bigger-picture decisions for their team and beyond.

The Strategic Researcher: turning insight into a competitive advantage

This researcher realized that the biggest challenge is not building features but figuring out which features to build that can differentiate the company. They used their research skills to discover that their competitors focused on acquiring new customers, but retention was the real pain point. Instead of copying others, they designed a team strategy that put retention and long-term customer loyalty at the center, leading to an overall increase in revenue.

The Facilitative Leader: strategy as a way to bring a team together

A talented facilitator was tasked with onboarding a brand-new team onto a high-stakes venture. Instead of waiting for things to fall into place, he pitched a strategy project before the real work started. Within months, the team was running toward the same vision, avoiding the typical months of confusion and inefficiency that new teams face.

The Customer Expert: finding common ground between design and engineering

A designer was struggling to find their place in a dev-centric organization. When pitching improvements to design, they would get pushback from engineers who didn’t agree with his ideas to improve the look and feel of the product. The designer initiated a strategy project, and his research led him to focus on onboarding as a customer problem spot. Rather than pitching changes to the design, he pitched modifications to the customer experience, and he slowly developed a product strategy around onboarding and ensuring customers knew how to use the product, giving him more leadership and influence on the product team.

Stepping Off the Treadmill

It can be disorienting when you finally get off that treadmill of reacting.

[GIF by thechemicalbrothers]

It’s uncomfortable to stop reacting. Manufactured urgency, such as arbitrary deadlines, competitive pressures, and stakeholder demands, can keep teams running so hard they forget why they started running in the first place.

Stepping back to think big-picture is necessary to:

  • Escape the cycle of reactive work.
  • Find leverage instead of just effort.
  • Make intentional decisions.
  • Break free from survival mode & shape the future.

It’s helpful when leadership decides it’s time to step off the treadmill, but that might not be the case for you. Usually, there is “already a strategy” that everybody is ignoring, so it can be hard to make the case for stepping off the treadmill to be more strategic.

That’s the reality of strategy today: everyone thinks they have a strategy, but most aren’t very good.

Here are some ways to be more proactive about strategy when you don’t have a mandate from leadership:

  1. Use the Socratic method.

    If you know where you want to lead the strategy, asking the right questions can help leaders realize what you want them to see without requiring you to say anything negative.

    For example, if the strategy is too vague and full of goals (a common issue), you might say: “I like the strategy here, and the goals are very inspiring. What specific actions or decisions will these goals guide? If someone on our team asked, ‘What should I do today to contribute to this goal?’—would they have a clear answer?”

  2. Share content from strategy experts.

    A nice way to gently nudge leadership away from an idea is to offer educational sources to help them change their minds. If you are careful, you can share this information without making it feel like you are attacking anyone.

    For example, if the strategy is too aspirational and doesn’t face the company’s problem (a common issue), you might send them an article: Build a Strategy that Addresses Your Gnarliest Challenges by Richard Rumelt. The right article from a trusted source might be enough to change their mind.

  3. Campaign for an update to the strategy.

    If you have the authority, you might try openly campaigning for an update to the strategy. Make sure you’re well-versed in strategy theory and understand the current strategy and the leadership team. You don’t want to campaign against something you don’t understand.

    For example, you might mention the strategy’s shortcomings and volunteer to come up with an update. Make sure you pitch for enough time to properly research the strategy (but take my strategy course first if you don’t know what the process looks like).

  4. Call it something else and pitch that.

    If you want to be proactive about doing strategy, you don’t have to pitch a strategy project per se, especially if there is already a strategy and that would be politically dangerous. You can call strategy pretty much anything you like and pitch for time to work on that instead.

    For example, you might call it a “metrics project” and work to develop a new set of metrics that will guide the team in your chosen strategic direction. While metrics are normally only a small aspect of a strategy, you can pretend that metrics are the whole thing while using the time to research and design a better strategy.

  5. Start working on a team-level strategy, then scale it up.

    You might try working on a new strategy for your team (known as a functional strategy) until you have something to show before pitching a new company strategy. Most people can get away with pitching a strategy for their team without raising eyebrows. The team-level strategy can give you valuable practice for the high-risk company strategy.

    For example, you might just start working on a strategy with your colleagues at your team’s level. Think big with the strategy, but test it on your team. Once you have a theory and some data, it will be easier to scale the thinking to the whole company. I do this in my strategy course, and I have seen a team-level strategy scale up to the company level a few times. It takes a while, but it’s safer than starting with the company strategy.

  6. Recruit an outside consultant.

    It’s hard to read the label from inside the bottle, and your company has the same problem with being able to judge their strategy. You don’t have to be an expert to know when a strategy sucks, but you might need an expert to fix it. An outside consultant can give valuable fresh eyes, provides a new source of trust, and won’t be as dangerous politically as you updating the strategy.

    For example, you might hire a strategy consultant under the guise of some other project, then have them try to influence leadership into updating the strategy. (If you need a consultant, book a call, and let’s talk. I can subtly push for a new strategic initiative while giving you the credit.)

It’s about the long game

[GIF by dualvoidanima]

Strategy is about making the future happen on your terms, rather than reacting to it as it unfolds. It’s about seeing beyond the next urgent demand and focusing on the bigger picture.

The best companies, teams, and individuals don’t just react to market pressures. They take a step back and work to shape the future.

If you would like some help kickstarting a strategy project, I’m here to help. Book a call with me, and we can figure it out together.

The best time to start thinking strategically was yesterday. The second-best time is now.